Rene Solorzano3 min readMany rent-versus-buy comparisons ask whether a mortgage payment costs more than rent. That question leaves out the largest number in the comparison: the cash that goes into the house and stops earning anything else. If you put $58,500 into a purchase, the $50,000 down payment and $8,500 in closing costs, you give up whatever that money would have earned in the meantime.
Here's a concrete case, and it's the example the rest of this article uses. You're considering a $425,000 home with $50,000 down, against $2,200 a month in rent. The mortgage is 6.5% over 30 years, which leaves a $375,000 loan. Property taxes run 1.2% of value, insurance 0.5%, and maintenance 1%. Because your down payment is under 20%, private mortgage insurance (PMI) applies as well. Those costs bring your starting monthly housing cost to about $3,452. If you rent instead, you keep $56,300 invested at 8.5% and get your $2,200 deposit back at the end. Your rent rises 3% a year, and the home appreciates 4% a year.
Start with the capital. At 8.5%, compounded annually, $56,300 grows to about $84,700 in five years. That's a gain of roughly $28,400 from the money alone, before any monthly savings. Each percentage point of return changes that figure by about $3,900 over five years. At 7.5%, the gain is about $24,500. At 9.5%, it's about $32,300.
The rest follows from there. Your home rises from $425,000 to about $518,900 over five years. The mortgage balance falls to about $351,000, and a 6% selling cost takes about $31,100 off the top. That leaves you with about $136,700 of net wealth. Had you rented and invested instead, you'd end with about $172,400, including your deposit. The difference is about $35,600 in favor of renting.
Your monthly savings from renting do most of the work. Renting invests the monthly gap between the two housing costs as it occurs. Without that stream, your capital alone would reach about $86,900 with the deposit, and buying would come out ahead by roughly $50,000. The savings turn that buyer lead into a renter lead.
You do build equity, and the home does appreciate. But in this example, your gains end up smaller than what you gave up, once the mortgage interest, ownership costs, and selling costs are counted.
| Buy | Rent | |
|---|---|---|
| Money committed at the start | $58,500 into the home | $56,300 invested, plus a $2,200 deposit |
| Starting monthly housing cost | Starting monthly housing cost | Starting monthly housing cost |
| Value after five years | About $518,900 home | About $170,200 portfolio |
| Mortgage still owed | About $351,000 | None |
| Exit costs | About $31,100 | None |
| Net wealth at year five | About $136,700 | About $172,400 |
The answer depends on how long you hold. Within five years, the costs of buying and selling weigh heavily. The Rent vs. Buy Calculator's horizon benchmarks suggest renting is the likelier winner for one to three years and buying for ten years or more. Five years falls in the range where market conditions decide, so the investment return and the appreciation rate matter more than any single monthly figure.
Those two rates are the assumptions to test. Raise appreciation, and your home gains more. Raise the investment return, and your invested capital gains more. Faster rent growth works in the other direction, shrinking your monthly savings.
Looking only at monthly payments misses this. You may find that the mortgage costs less than rent each month and still end with less wealth, because your down payment and closing costs were tied up in the house. You may also find that rent costs more each month and still comes out ahead, because your capital kept working. Before you buy, the question worth answering is what your down payment would earn elsewhere, since that figure drives most of the outcome.
Start by checking how much home fits your income and debts with the Home Affordability Calculator, then compare the two paths over your expected holding period in the Rent vs. Buy Calculator.